Lord John Grey And Black Jack Randall
Episode 3 of Outlander Season 3 may have taken away Tobias Menzies' Frank Randall, but it gave us back two pivotal characters in return: Murtagh (Duncan Lacroix), and Lord John William Grey, who has grown up into the dashing form of Australian actor David Berry.
SEE ALSO: 'Outlander' episode 3 makes one huge change from the books; showrunner Ron Moore explains why
Regaining Murtagh gives us an important tie to Jamie's past, but Lord John could offer a promising hint about Outlander's future.
But since the issue of rape was presented with such gravity, and since a great gay character named Lord John Grey should be showing up soon if they stay close to the books, I'm choosing to stay. Jonathan 'Black Jack' Randall (3) Wulfric (Outlander 2008) (3) Kainan (Outlander 2008) (3) Laoghaire MacKenzie (3) Lord John Grey (2) Include Relationships Claire Beauchamp/Jamie Fraser (7) Kainan/Wulfric (2) Jamie Fraser/Jonathan 'Black Jack' Randall (2) Jamie Fraser/Lord John Grey (2) Claire Beauchamp/Frank Randall (1). Posted August 11, 2017 by primrosesandrue16 in Black Jack Randall, David Berry, Jamie Fraser, Lord John Grey, Outlander, Season 3, Stills, Tobias Menzies. Tagged with BTS, David Berry, Outlander, Sam Heughan, Tobias Menzies. Jamie Fraser/Lord John Grey (118) Claire Beauchamp/Frank Randall (92) Brianna Randall Fraser MacKenzie/Roger MacKenzie Wakefield (89). Fergus Fraser/Marsali McKimmie Fraser (37) Jamie Fraser/Jonathan 'Black Jack' Randall (20) Exclude Additional Tags Alternate Universe - Modern Setting (447) Fluff (169) Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence.
We're reintroduced to John Grey as the unfortunate new governor of Ardsmuir Prison. For fans who need a refresher, the show reminds us that he previously had a life-changing encounter with Jamie Fraser (Sam Heughan) before the clash at Prestonpans, when the young nobleman tried — and thankfully failed — to assassinate our heroic Highlander, before Jamie and Claire tricked John (at the time going by William) into revealing the whereabouts of the nearby English troops, thus giving the Scots the edge in the ensuing battle.
Their friendship faces the immediate roadblock of Lord John being an English soldier who has already tried to kill Jamie once (awkward), and matters aren't helped when the governor — who subtly reveals that he's gay in a powerful moment of vulnerability between the two men — makes a romantic overture towards Jamie, instantly bringing back all the trauma Jamie suffered at the hands of another redcoat in a position of authority. Despite the agony of the moment, Heughan and Berry bring such humanity and pathos to their scenes together, it's impossible to look away.
As Roxane Gay notes in her recap of episode 3, 'the only shame of this storyline is that it is, as queer storylines often tend to be in popular culture, grounded in loss, sorrow, and unrequited feelings.'
But we can't really blame John for falling for 'king of men' Jamie Fraser. After all, there are plenty of women over the course of the series who suffer the same unreciprocated desire, and unlike Black Jack Randall, John understands the importance of consent (SPOILER ALERT: the books reveal that John was also raped while in the army).
After that momentary lapse in judgment, John consciously keeps his distance and attempts to earn back Jamie's fragile trust by offering him the closest thing to freedom he can manage: parole at a wealthy lord's estate.
Fans of Diana Gabaldon's novels know that Lord John plays an important role in the series going forward — both in Jamie and Claire's lives and as the protagonist in his own books and novellas — and his inclusion is particularly meaningful considering that the character is gay, 'in a time when to be homosexual was a capital offense,' as Gabaldon notes.
His inclusion allows the show to reframe its complicated relationship with homosexuality; the writers, actors and Gabaldon have all emphasized that Black Jack Randall's fascination with Jamie was driven by his sadistic tendencies, not his orientation (he also had no compunctions about torturing women, as Claire can attest) — but it's inevitable that Jamie would instinctively view any male attention as predatory in light of that experience.
Unfortunately, the 'depraved homosexual' trope is one that pop culture has reinforced with disturbing frequency over the years, so it's refreshing that Gabaldon sought to subvert that stereotype by allowing John to be the hero of his own story, as well as an important (if tertiary) player in Jamie and Claire's.
But Outlander is Claire and Jamie's story, so the show can't (and shouldn't) devote much real-estate to John beyond his connection with our beloved central couple. Not to mention, John's interactions with Jamie — while respectfully platonic — will always be colored by his unrequited feelings moving forward; which is why we're rooting for Starz and Sony to follow Gabaldon's lead and develop a Lord John spinoff series, which would allow him to flourish into the fully-formed character he's become in the books.
SEE ALSO: 'Outlander' Season 3: Ten burning questions we have about Claire and Jamie's reunion
We recently asked Outlander showrunner Ron Moore if there were any plans for the character to anchor his own show, and he admitted, 'you're always thinking about such things, but there is nothing in really active development.'
In addition to being a rare homosexual character in a major literary series who drives his own narrative — especially remarkable given the repressive time period he inhabits — John's journey is endlessly fascinating to readers and the author because, as Gabaldon explains, 'Lord John has more than most to lose by discovery. He belongs to a noble family, he’s an officer in His Majesty’s Army, and loves both his family and his regiment; to have his private life discovered would damage—if not destroy—both. Consequently, he lives constantly with conflict, which makes him both deeply entertaining and easy to write about.'
Another mark in the spinoff's favor? Outlander's executive producers definitely seem to be fans of Berry's work so far. 'He's just a really good actor,' says Matt Roberts, who wrote episode 303. 'We had to have somebody that could play against both Sam and Caitriona and stand up to them, and we knew right off the bat… that’s the guy.'
Lord John is a compelling and complex character regardless of his sexuality — especially when embodied with such nuance by Berry — but a show centered around him would be a particularly welcome addition to the pop culture landscape, since TV still has a long way to go in its portrayal of homosexual heroes.
While GLAAD reports that the 2016-17 TV season had the highest percentage of LGBTQ series regular characters ever recorded on broadcast (4.8 percent, which amounts to 43 out of 895 series regulars), many of those characters are members of an ensemble rather than the show's primary protagonist.
Comedies have historically been more welcoming to LGBTQ leads, but dramas still lag behind — American TV has yet to produce an LGBTQ action hero half as compelling as Torchwood's Captain Jack Harkness — although the CW has come closest with Clarke on The 100 and Legends of Tomorrow's Sara Lance.
SEE ALSO: Director makes trailer showing why the world needs LGBT superheroes
But even when dramas do feature a gay, lesbian or bisexual hero, it doesn't always insulate them from problematic narratives, as demonstrated by the fan backlash against The 100 after the show unceremoniously killed off Lexa, Clarke's love interest, in Season 3. (GLAAD notes that at least 12 lesbian and bisexual female characters were killed on broadcast shows during 2016 — a staggering number given how few LGBTQ characters exist in the first place.)
A Lord John spinoff series obviously couldn't fix all of TV's shortcomings when it comes to LGBTQ representation (GLAAD's report also notes that 72% of LGBTQ characters on cable and 71% on streaming are white, so Lord John's no help there), but it could certainly explore a type of story that's rarely portrayed — allowing a gay character to anchor an action-adventure or fantasy series in a way that TV shows and mainstream Hollywood blockbusters are still hesitant to allow.
Plus, by exploring the daily reality of being a homosexual man in the 18th century, with all its inherent secrecy and danger, the show would have an organic way to widen John's world and introduce other LGBTQ characters who might otherwise be pushed to the margins in a period drama.
A post shared by Outlander (@outlander_starz) on
And leaving aside the hero's orientation, Gabaldon's Lord John stories are just a rollicking good read — blending historical mystery with romance, politics and family drama to create narratives every bit as compelling as Outlander's, which makes them ripe for adaptation.
The Lord John novels take place in the same period currently being explored on this season of Outlander, while Jamie is paroled at Helwater, but given the timeline-jumping nature of the show, fans are no strangers to following storylines taking place in two different eras.
And while we wouldn't want anything to affect the quality of Outlander — which sometimes happens when creative teams split their attention between multiple projects — a Lord John spinoff seems like a smart bet from a business and creative standpoint: the character already has an inbuilt fanbase and a charismatic leading man attached; networks are always looking for franchise potential for their properties, which concurrently adds more value to the flagship show; Outlander has already provided a kind of backdoor pilot by introducing Lord John in Season 3; and an LGBTQ hero fits Starz's mandate to cater to underserved audiences who are hungry to see characters like them represented on screen.
Seems like a win-win to us — but even if a Lord John spinoff doesn't materialize, we're looking forward to the distinctive voice he'll bring to Outlander for many seasons to come.
Watch: 'Outlander' Season 3 is a heartbreaker
What is the Lord John Grey series?
It’s a subset of the main OUTLANDER series, focused on Lord John Grey, an important minor character from the main series.
Some years ago, I was invited to write a short story for a British anthology: historical crime stories. “Well,” I said to the editor, “it would be an interesting technical challenge, to see whether I can write anything under 300,000 words. Sure, why not?”
Well, the obvious first question was—what or whom to write about? I didn’t want to use the main characters from the OUTLANDER series for this story, because—owing to the peculiar way I write—if I were to incorporate some significant event in this story (and it would need to be, to be a good story)—that would make the event a stumbling block in the growth of the next novel.
Lord John Grey
“But,” I said to myself, “there’s Lord John, isn’t there?” Lord John Grey is an important character in the OUTLANDER series, but he isn’t onstage all the time. And when he isn’t…well, plainly he’s off leading his life and having adventures elsewhere, and I could write about any of those adventures without causing complications for future novels. Beyond that obvious advantage, Lord John is a fascinating character. He’s what I call a “mushroom”—one of those unplanned people who pops up out of nowhere and walks off with any scene he’s in—and he talks to me easily (and wittily).
He’s also a gay man, in a time when to be homosexual was a capital offense, and Lord John has more than most to lose by discovery. He belongs to a noble family, he’s an officer in His Majesty’s Army, and loves both his family and his regiment; to have his private life discovered would damage—if not destroy—both. Consequently, he lives constantly with conflict, which makes him both deeply entertaining and easy to write about. So I wrote the short story—titled, “Lord John and the Hell-Fire Club”—for the British anthology.
Well, it was a good story; people liked it. But just as word was spreading into the US about it, the anthology went out of print (it was called PAST POISONS, edited by Maxim Jakubowski, for those bibliophiles who are curious). People kept asking me about the story, though, and I thought, “Well, I enjoyed writing it—maybe I should write two or three more short pieces about Lord John, just as time an inspiration allow…and when I have a handful, we could publish them as a book, and all the Lord John fans could get the stories easily.”
So I did that. I began writing the second Lord John story after returning from a book-tour, as a way of easing back into my writing routine, and continued working on it, picking away with one hand whilst picking up the threads of my novel with the other…and six months later, I’d just about finished it. Well, at this point, I left for another book-tour, in the UK, and stopped in New York on the way, to have lunch with my two literary agents.
I was telling them all about what I’d been doing, and casually mentioned that I’d nearly finished the second Lord John short story. “Oh?” said they. “How long’s this one?”
“Well, I knew you’d ask,” I said. “So I checked last night. It’s about 85,000 words; I need maybe another 5000 to wrap it up.”
The agents looked at each other, then looked at me, and with one voice said, “That’s the size normal books are!”
“I thought it was a short story,” I said.
“Well, it’s not,” they said—and proceeded to take it off and sell it all over the place. Publishers were thrilled. “It’s a Gabaldon book we weren’t expecting—and it’s short! Can she do that again?” they asked eagerly. To which my agents—being Very Good agents—replied, “Of course she can,” and emerged with a contract for three Lord John Grey novels.
Now, the Lord John books and novellas are in fact an integral part of the larger OUTLANDER series. However, they’re focused (not unreasonably) on the character of John Grey, and—Lord John not being a time-traveler—tend not to include time-travel as an element. They’re structured more or less as historical mystery, but do (like anything else I write) include the occasional supernatural bit or other off-the-wall elements. (Yes, they do have sex, though I don’t consider that really unusual, myself.) And they do reference events, characters (particularly Jamie Fraser) and situations from the OUTLANDER novels.
In terms of chronology, the Lord John books fall during the period covered in VOYAGER, while Jamie Fraser was a prisoner at Helwater. So if you’re wondering where to read the Lord John books in conjunction with the larger series—you can read them anytime after VOYAGER.
In terms of further chronology: As well as the three Lord John novels under contract, I’ve also written several novellas for various anthologies. Three novellas (two previously published and one written specifically for the volume) are included in a book titled LORD JOHN AND THE HAND OF DEVILS, while two further novellas have appeared or will shortly appear in anthologies. The original short story (“Hell-Fire Club”) preceded the first novel, and—just to be confusing—the novellas fall between the novels.
The books and novellas do stand alone, and can be read separately in any order. If you do want to read them in strict order, though, here it is:
Lord Randall Song
- “Lord John and the Hellfire Club,” a short story. Originally published in PAST POISONS, ed. Maxim Jakubowski. Collected in LORD JOHN AND THE HAND OF DEVILS.
- LORD JOHN AND THE PRIVATE MATTER, a novel.
- “Lord John and the Succubus,” a novella, originally published in LEGENDS II: Short novels by the Masters of Modern Fantasy, edited by Robert Silverberg. Collected in LORD JOHN AND THE HAND OF DEVILS.
- LORD JOHN AND THE BROTHERHOOD OF THE BLADE, a novel.
- “Lord John and the Haunted Soldier,” a novella. Published only in LORD JOHN AND THE HAND OF DEVILS.
- LORD JOHN AND THE HAND OF DEVILS, a book-length collection of three novellas: “Hell-Fire Club,” “Succubus,” and “Haunted Soldier.”
- “Lord John and the Custom of the Army,” a novella, originally published in WARRIORS (volume 1), edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois.
- THE SCOTTISH PRISONER, a novel. Released on November 29, 2011.
- “Lord John and the Plague of Zombies,” which is also titled, “A Plague of Zombies,” a novella. Appeared in DOWN THESE STRANGE STREETS, edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois, released in October, 2011.
Lord John Grey And Black Jack Randall Moore
Below are excerpts from web pages for each of the Lord John novels and stories: